Everyone knows the saying ‘communication is key’, but how do you implement this concept to your managers?
Usually, people think of only giving feedback to team members, rather than their leaders. However, giving feedback to all team members, including your managers, can be a step in the right direction for improving happiness at work and business success.
In this guide, we’ll give you tips and guidance while also providing lots of manager feedback examples so you’ll not only feel more confident discussing issues with your boss, but also help you handle communication challenges more widely.
Our blog post will encourage you to feel like the best version of yourself, so you can provide any feedback you may want to give without worry.
Why giving feedback to management is important
Everyone knows communication is important in any relationship, but why is it specifically important for managers?
Well, feedback for manager positions can help you in numerous ways. It can:
Help management improve: Open conversations with management means that they’ll be able to utilize this feedback to develop as a professional, making the management more effective.
Encourage productivity: Open communication will create a more productive workforce, as your workforce will be happier and feel able to openly express themselves. This means that everyone will be more encouraged to work harder.
Improve your communication skills: Communication is a great transferrable skill which is why it’s so important to foster it. It’s an important skill to have as it allows you to avoid misunderstandings, meaning you can in turn avoid wider conflict.
Help problem-solving skills: Again, being a problem-solver is a great transferrable skill, both in and out of work. Identifying issues with management, communicating it clearly and addressing your challenges takes a lot of courage, but makes a world of difference!
In nearly all cases, management feedback is important to company culture. It helps to foster a feedback culture and prioritizes learning and development. Positivity in the workplace usually requires positive management. Therefore, being aware of some great manager feedback examples is sure to help you strike the right note when you discuss any feedback with your manager.
Constructive feedback for manager positions, when delivered with respect may help you earn your leader’s trust.
When communicated tactfully all feedback (good or bad) will foster a strong relationship with your leaders, helping you improve future communication.
Not only this, but feedback for your manager also empowers both the employee and the employer, so you’ve got the confidence to speak up in the future. After all, a problem shared is a problem halved.
When to give feedback to your manager
If your company has a period designated for feedback, for example, quarterly, bi-annual, or annual reviews this is the time to do it. By delivering your feedback, you’ll demonstrate valuable insight and the will to improve your team’s dynamic and performance.
However, sometimes there isn’t a designated time for feedback, and that’s fine! You’ll have to make your own opportunities, which can feel daunting; however, we’ve created a list below to help you identify your chance to issue feedback.
It is great to provide feedback when:
- You’re in one-on-one meetings
- You’re in team meetings if you and your manager feel comfortable in this group setting
- Your manager asks for feedback
Setting up a meeting ahead of time means that your feedback is structured rather than just impulsive.
When to avoid giving feedback to your manager
Feedback can be a great way to promote a healthier, more successful team, that is confident in its dynamic feedback culture.
However, there are occasions when giving feedback isn’t the best idea. Here’s a few times when you shouldn’t:
- You're in the heat of the moment
- You're in front of your manager’s superiors
- Your manager seems stressed
- You’re feeling very frustrated
- HR should be involved instead
- You’ve just started a new role, and your rapport may not be developed yet
In most cases, it’s best to use your best judgment to decide when the manager feedback examples we have provided should be used.
Specifically, really consider negative feedback. You’ll need to be sure of your opinions, and be able to clearly articulate what the problem is. Otherwise, you might be at risk of blowing your chance to deliver feedback.
Types of feedback
Feedback can be given in lots of different ways. For example, the feedback you provide can depend on your situation or environment.
Regardless of these factors, being honest, clear, succinct and polite in your communication is a recipe for success when offering opinions to management.
We’ll outline the different feedback you can offer to your management to help you understand this a bit clearer:
Positive feedback for your manager examples
Letting your manager know they’ve done a great job is always a great feeling. And it’s the easiest to implement of all the feedback approaches.
You can bring this feedback up in meetings or simply in casual conversation. When you decide to offer this feedback is up to you, but be assured you’ll be supporting your manager while also helping build company morale at the same time – a true win-win.
Positive feedback to manager examples could be: “Your positivity really helped me as it boosted my morale and made me feel recognized in the team as you celebrated our successes.”
Here’s a few more examples of positive feedback you could use:
- “I know that finding the correct balance within the workplace can often be hard and takes a lot of effort, however, your specific style of management really has made a difference and has pushed me to accomplish things I never thought I could do."
- “Thank you for all the help you’ve given in providing me with clear detail and direction for this task.”
- “I find that I thrive with clear instructions and direction, therefore your consistent involvement and clear communication have helped me to succeed.”
Constructive feedback for manager examples
Constructive feedback is the type of feedback that is given with the intention of a positive outcome.
Make sure you’re communicating clearly and in a structured way when offering constructive feedback. This will avoid any miscommunications and will ensure you’re conveying the point you want to put across rather than simply confusing your manager.
Here are a few examples of constructive feedback:
- "I’d benefit from a conversation about the decision you made about ‘x’, so I can understand your choice better.”
- “I want to make sure we're on the same page because I know you have high expectations for me, however, micromanagement is making it hard for me to progress.”
A few phrases that may enable you to give clear feedback could be:
- “I think there is room for improvement here…”
- “Our team could benefit from…”
- “A better way to handle this could be…”
- “I see an opportunity to improve this, in this way”
Negative feedback for manager examples
Negative feedback is hard to give, however, giving this feedback is important as, if warranted, it can be the right thing to do.
Offering this type of feedback can help deliver better business outcomes and help your manager and your team grow and develop.
Negative feedback can feel difficult to deliver. However taking a step back, understanding the issue and communicating calmly and clearly can relieve some of the tension you might be feeling.
Here are a few examples of negative feedback:
- “I think the team would benefit drastically from some positivity even when work is tough."
- “I believe that the team needs to be set clear goals, within our training. Currently, I feel as though we are all receiving insufficient training which is making it harder to understand what is expected of us all.”
- If you’re feeling overwhelmed with how your day is being scheduled you could say something like, “Recently, I have been feeling stressed because my workload feels unmanageable. I’d appreciate it if my tasks could be prioritized differently, so I can work in ways that suit my working style best, meaning I’ll be able to get more done in the day.”
- “Over the past few months, I’ve noticed that the work is being distributed unfairly between my colleagues. My workload needs to lessen so I can complete my work to the best quality possible.”
Feedback to manager examples and tips
When giving feedback to managers, it’s important to give effective feedback.
Regardless of whether you’re communicating positive feedback for manager positions or constructive feedback to managers, you must be:
- Specific: Be specific when things have gone well
- Timely: Give feedback shortly after something has happened - this way it’ll be fresh in everyone’s minds.
- Objective: Removing yourself from the situation emotionally, when required, means that you can focus on what has happened, rather than your emotions.
- Respectful: Being respectful of your manager’s feelings when communicating, will ensure that your feedback is emotionally intelligent and also sensitive to how your manager may be feeling too.
How to give feedback to your manager?
Providing feedback to your manager can be a delicate process, but there are some general good practices that are safe to follow. Communication, whether it's praise or suggestions for improvement, is crucial. Here are some proven strategies for giving feedback to your manager that can help foster a positive and productive dialogue.
Start with positive feedback
Always start with something positive before delving into critical feedback. This sets a constructive tone for the conversation. Mention specific instances where the manager excelled. For example, "Your guidance on the recent project was invaluable." Share positive feedback to show appreciation and balance the discussion. This approach makes it easier to segue into areas needing improvement, ensuring the manager remains open and receptive.
Be specific and clear
When providing feedback, be specific and clear. Vague comments can be confusing and unhelpful. Use constructive feedback examples to illustrate your points. Instead of saying, "Your communication needs improvement," try, "During our team meetings, I noticed that some direct reports feel their ideas are not heard." Clear, actionable feedback helps your manager understand exactly what to work on.
Choose the right time and place
Provide timely feedback in an appropriate setting. Address issues soon after they occur but choose a private, distraction-free environment. Feedback conversations should be handled with care to ensure they are productive. For instance, avoid giving feedback during a stressful period or in public. A well-timed conversation enhances the effectiveness of your feedback and respects the manager's dignity.
Use "I" statements
Using "I" statements can make giving constructive criticism less confrontational. For example, "I feel that the team's morale could improve with more recognition of their efforts." This approach focuses on your perspective and feelings rather than making accusatory statements. It makes providing constructive feedback more personal and less likely to be perceived as an attack.
Focus on behaviors, not personality
When providing honest feedback, focus on specific behaviors rather than personality traits. Discuss actions that can be changed rather than inherent qualities. For instance, say, "I noticed that meetings often run over time," instead of "You are disorganized." This makes the feedback more actionable and constructive. Constructive criticism should aim to improve the manager's performance, not undermine their character.
Encourage a two-way conversation
Encourage a two-way conversation to ensure receiving feedback is as valued as providing feedback. Ask for your manager's perspective and be open to their input. This fosters a healthy feedback process where both parties can learn and grow. For example, "How do you think we can improve our team meetings?" This approach builds a collaborative working relationship.
Prepare for the conversation
Prepare for the feedback conversation by outlining your points and examples. Reflect on how feedback for managers can be delivered constructively. Being well-prepared helps you stay focused and calm. For instance, jot down instances where timely manner feedback would have been beneficial. Preparation shows respect for the manager and the importance of the feedback.
Offer support and follow-up
After sharing feedback, offer support and discuss next steps. Show that you are committed to helping improve the situation. For example, "I can help track meeting times if that would be useful." Follow up to discuss progress and any further professional development needed. Continuous support and timely feedback ensure that the feedback leads to positive changes and strengthens the working relationship.
Address discomfort directly
If you feel uncomfortable giving feedback, acknowledge it but emphasize the importance of honest feedback for growth. "I find it challenging to bring this up, but I believe it is important for our team's success." Addressing your discomfort openly can set a respectful tone and encourage constructive criticism. It shows your commitment to the feedback process and your direct report relationship.
Common misconceptions about giving feedback to your manager
Providing feedback to your manager can be challenging, often surrounded by misconceptions. Here, we address and clarify three common myths to improve your understanding of employee feedback and its impact.
Myth 1: Upward feedback is always negative
Many believe that upward feedback is inherently critical or negative. This is misleading because effective feedback should include both positive reinforcement and areas for improvement. Sharing what your manager does well can boost their confidence and reinforce good practices, making the feedback process more balanced and constructive.
Myth 2: Giving feedback can damage your relationship with your manager
Some employees fear that providing feedback will harm their relationship with their manager. In reality, when done respectfully and constructively, feedback can strengthen the working relationship. It shows that you are invested in mutual growth and improvement, fostering a culture of open communication and trust.
Myth 3: Feedback should only focus on the manager's performance
While it's crucial to address the manager's performance, feedback should also consider the broader impact on the team. Discuss how the manager's actions affect the direct report and overall team dynamics. As a result, feedback promotes the effectiveness of the whole team, not just the individual's performance.
When and how to escalate the situation
Sometimes, even the most crystal-clear communication and well-intentioned feedback efforts go in vain because the manager does not apply the feedback provided. In such cases, it's important to know when and how to escalate the situation to ensure your concerns are addressed.
Escalation should be approached thoughtfully and professionally to maintain a positive work environment. Here are some solutions on what can be done and how to escalate the situation effectively.
Document your feedback and efforts
Before escalating, ensure that you have documented all instances of feedback and the efforts made to address the issues. Keep records of emails, meeting notes, and any other relevant communications. Such documentation will provide a clear history of the steps taken and can be crucial in supporting your case when you escalate the situation to higher management.
Seek advice from HR or a trusted colleague
HR or peer consulting can provide valuable insights and advice on how to proceed with the escalation. They can offer guidance on company policies and the best practices for addressing such issues. HR can also act as a mediator and help facilitate a constructive conversation between you and your manager.
Request a formal meeting with higher management
If the situation remains unresolved, request a formal meeting with higher management. Present your documented feedback and explain the impact of the manager's inaction on your work and the team. Be clear and concise about the issues and the steps you've taken to address them. It shows you have tried to resolve the matter independently and are now seeking additional assistance.
Focus on solutions, not just problems
When escalating, it's important to focus on potential solutions rather than just highlighting problems. Propose actionable steps that can help resolve the issues and improve the situation. Taking a proactive approach shows your commitment to resolving issues and creating a positive outcome.
Maintain professionalism throughout the process
Throughout the escalation process, maintain professionalism and avoid letting emotions dictate your actions. Stay calm, respectful, and objective when discussing the issues with higher management. Professionalism ensures that your concerns are taken seriously and that the escalation process remains productive.
Consider a mediation session
If direct escalation to higher management does not resolve the issue, consider requesting a mediation session. Mediation involves a neutral third party who helps facilitate a discussion between you and your manager to reach a mutual understanding and resolution. Both parties can express their concerns and work together to find a solution. Mediation can be especially useful in maintaining a positive working relationship and ensuring that both sides feel heard and respected.
To wrap up
Well-executed feedback given to your managers can promote honest and open conversations in the workplace. Our manager feedback examples should work as a springboard to encourage you to actively discuss various feedback points with your manager, to help you clearly put your points across and therefore set clear goals for the future.
If you want to automate workflows, manage contacts, track your sales pipeline, and more then try Capsule for free for 14 days and you’ll see a difference in efficiency.
